(Updated) Trump’s potential view of a reinstated Yoon: “Step down”

If Yoon is reinstated on Friday, Yoon will quickly ask to meet Trump at the White House within 30 days. It's entirely possible the White House will convey to Yoon that he would not be welcomed in DC, and the President thinks it's in the best interests of the ROK and the alliance that Yoon resign.

Dr. Mark P. Barry☯︎ (@drmarkpbarry.bsky.social) 2025-04-01T14:48:49.268Z

Essentially, Trump may not want Yoon to return, not only because he's damaged goods, but because he's a provably unreliable ally as well as someone under indictment. Better Yoon resign, start afresh, and let someone be duly elected within 60 days – who Trump can then put in his place, per usual.

Dr. Mark P. Barry☯︎ (@drmarkpbarry.bsky.social) 2025-04-01T14:53:42.794Z

Trump's position on a reinstated Yoon may be that "if you stuck it to Biden, you could do it to me, while we keep 28,500 troops in the ROK. I won't give you the chance to do that to the President of the United States." Trump would be telling Yoon to immediately step down and let elections be held.

Dr. Mark P. Barry☯︎ (@drmarkpbarry.bsky.social) 2025-04-01T16:44:20.534Z

To be clear, Trump may take a wait and see attitude toward Yoon, but if Yoon asks to meet asap, at best Trump will be noncommittal; at worst, Trump will have someone like Waltz convey to the ROK that the US does not have full confidence in Yoon and believes it's best for the alliance if he resigns.

Dr. Mark P. Barry☯︎ (@drmarkpbarry.bsky.social) 2025-04-02T02:03:30.841Z

Of course, Trump could accept Yoon's reinstatement simply because he needs South Korea to be a reliable security ally and so someone is duly in charge in the ROK. But Yoon's policy toward North Korea conflicts with Trump's desire to dialogue with Kim Jong-un, which could lead to Trump ignoring Yoon.

Dr. Mark P. Barry☯︎ (@drmarkpbarry.bsky.social) 2025-04-02T16:12:19.947Z

The Constitutional Court’s ruling on Yoon’s impeachment will be announced at 11 a.m. KT on April 4 (10 pm ET April 3). Here is Arirang News’ outline of three verdict scenarios:

The Constitutional Court’s ruling on President Yoon Suk Yeol’s fate comes tomorrow. The president will be absent. Our correspondent Oh Soo-young explains potential scenarios on Friday:

“The fate of President Yoon Suk Yeol and the nation hangs on the Constitutional Court’s decision on his impeachment Friday. The ruling will mean immediate consequences regarding the governance of the country as the leader’s removal or reinstatement spells out very different outcomes.

If the Court upholds the impeachment, Yoon would become the nation’s second president in history to be removed from office—following Park Geun-hye’s impeachment eight years ago. Effective immediately, Yoon would have to vacate his office for good and leave the official residence in Yongsan-gu District. He would lose all post-presidential privileges—no pension, no office, no staff support, and no burial rights at the National Cemetery. His protection would be limited to basic personal security. With the leadership vacuum made permanent, Prime Minister Han Duck-soo would continue as Acting President until an early election is held within 60 days.

On the flip side, if the impeachment is dismissed with prejudice it would mean the Court has found the National Assembly’s grounds for his removal insufficient and the case is closed for good. After over three months of suspension, the President would immediately resume his duties. It’s expected he’d then address the public through a televised message or press conference.

His first tasks back in office are likely to focus first on foreign policy and national security, as there has not been top-level engagement with the United States since President Donald Trump’s inauguration. Yoon would also begin laying out proposals for constitutional and political reform, as pledged during his final court appearance.

While his impeachment case would be closed for good, Yoon would still face investigations regarding his Dec. 3 Martial Law declaration, but during his presidency, would be immune from charges other than for treason and insurrection.

Another scenario is the Court dismissing the case without prejudice. The case would be dropped due to legal or procedural issues, meaning the bench decided not to rule on the grounds or evidence presented. The President would return to office, but the National Assembly could reattempt impeachment in the future.

Six or more justices must consent to uphold an impeachment. Three or more justices deciding against impeachment would lead to a dismissal.

While sources say the justices have reached an understanding on the verdict, the bench is expected to sign off their decision at the last minute, either the evening before or early in the morning of the ruling, to maintain utmost confidentiality.

The ruling takes legal effect the moment the presiding justice reads the decision on live TV.

President Yoon’s lawyers told the press on Thursday that the suspended leader has decided not to go to the Court to hear his verdict in person, taking into the account the need to maintain public order, and presidential security arrangements.

In past impeachment cases, former Presidents Park Geun-hye and Roh Moo-hyun did not attend their ruling sessions either.

Oh Soo-young, Arirang News.”♦


Postscript: A unanimous Constitutional Court decision…

South Korea’s Impeached President Is Removed From Office Over Martial-Law Decree – WSJ http://www.wsj.com/world/asia/s…

Dr. Mark P. Barry☯︎ (@drmarkpbarry.bsky.social) 2025-04-04T02:33:01.217Z

Full transcript of South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol's impeachment ruling by Constitutional Court – The Korea Times http://www.koreatimes.co.kr/southkorea/p…

Dr. Mark P. Barry☯︎ (@drmarkpbarry.bsky.social) 2025-04-04T13:05:14.967Z

A week before Yoon took office, I met a seasoned ROK FM official in NYC. I said my advice for Yoon was to keep the lines of communication with Kim Jong Un open, even secretly, because closing the door on him would be a sign of disrespecting his efforts to dialogue with Trump. Yoon is now history.

Dr. Mark P. Barry☯︎ (@drmarkpbarry.bsky.social) 2025-04-04T05:46:08.870Z

Leave a comment